2024 Indian Scout Bobber vs 2025 BMW R 12G/S

Full specifications comparison • 2 motorcycles

Comparing 2 motorcycles
2024 Indian Scout Bobber 2024 Indian Scout Bobber

Custom / cruiser

Engine
Four stroke, 60° V-Twin, DOHC, 4 valves per cylinder
Power
107 hp / 79 kW @ 7250 rpm
Top Speed
N/A
Weight
237 kg / 522 lbs
2025 BMW R 12G/S 2025 BMW R 12G/S

Custom / cruiser

Engine
Four stroke, two cylinder horizontally opposed Boxer, with four camshaft-operated valves and two overhead camshafts per cylinder.
Power
81 kW / 109 hp @ 7000 rpm
Top Speed
N/A
Weight
229 kg / 505 lbs
Full Specifications
General
Year20242025
Make ModelIndian Scout BobberBMW R 12G/S
Dimensions
Seat Height649 mm / 25.5 in 860 mm / 33.9 in (875 mm / 34.4 in Enduro Package)
Wheelbase1562 mm / 61.5 in1580 mm / 62.2 in (1585 / 62.4 in Enduro Package)
Ground Clearance109 mm / 4.3 in-
Length2207 mm / 86.9 in2200 mm / 86.6 in
Width-830 mm / 32.7 in
Weights & Capacities
Dry Weight237 kg / 522 lbs-
Fuel Capacity13 Litres / 3.4 US gal15.5 Litres / 4.1 US gal
Maximum Load / GVWR449 kg / 988 lbs-
Wet Weight-229 kg / 505 lbs
Performance
Max Power107 hp / 79 kW @ 7250 rpm81 kW / 109 hp @ 7000 rpm
Max Torque79.7 lb-ft / 108 NM @ 6300 rpm115 Nm / 81 lb-ft @ 6500 rpm
Engine
Displacement1250 cc / 76 cu in1170 cc / 71.4 cub in
Engine DetailFour stroke, 60° V-Twin, DOHC, 4 valves per cylinderFour stroke, two cylinder horizontally opposed Boxer, with four camshaft-operated valves and two overhead camshafts per cylinder.
Bore x Stroke104 x 73.6 mm101 x 73 mm
Compression Ratio12.5:112:1
Cooling SystemLiquid CooledAir/oil cooled
Emissions-Controlled 3-way catalytic converter, exhaust emission standards EU-5+
Exhaust2-into-1-
Fuel InductionElectronic fuel injection, closed loop / 60 mm boreElectronic intake pipe injection / digital engine management system: BMS-O with throttle-by-wire
Fuel Type-Unleaded super (premium), octane number 95-98 (RON) (rated output at 98 RON)
LubricationSemi-Dry SumpWet sump
StarterElectricElectric
Drivetrain
ClutchWet, multi-plateSingle dry plate clutch, hydraulically operated
Final DriveBelt, 146 toothUniversal shaft
Gear Ratios1st 2.760:1, 2nd 1.882:1, 3rd 1.500:1, 4th 1.273:1, 5th 1.125:1, 5th 0.966:11st = 2.375, 2nd = 1.696, 3rd = 1.296, 4th = 1.065, 5th = 0.939, 6th = 0.848
Primary DriveGear drive wet clutch-
Primary Drive Ratios-1.737
Transmission / Drive6 Speed constant mesh, foot shift6-Speed, claw-shifted transmission with separate transmission housing
Chassis
Frame Type-Four-part frame concept with front frame and three-part rear frame, load-bearing engine-gearbox unit, rear-seat frame removeable for one-up riding
Suspension - Front41 mm Telescopic fork - cartridge type, adjustable45 mm USD telescopic forks, spring base, rebound and compression damping adjustable
Suspension - RearDual preload adjustable shocksAluminum Paralever swinging arm, directly linked WAD spring strut, spring base, rebound and compression damping adjustable
Rake29°-
Steering Head Angle-63.1° (63.2° Enduro Package)
Trail125 mm / 4.9 in120.8 mm / 4.76 in (121.3 / 4.76 Enduro Package)
Wheel Travel - Front119 mm / 4.7 in210 mm / 8.3 in
Wheel Travel - Rear50.8 mm / 2.0 in200 mm / 7.9 in
Wheels & Brakes
Brakes - FrontSingle 298 mm semi-floating disc with 2 piston caliper2 x 310mm disc brake, with two axially bolted 2-piston floating calipers
Brakes - RearSingle 298 mm semi-floating disc with 1 piston caliperSingle 265 mm disc, 2 piston floating caliper
ABS-BMW Motorrad ABS Pro (lean angle optimised)
Braking SystemIndividual front and rear control-
Rims - Front-2.15 x 21
Rims - Rear-4.0 x 17 (4.0 x 18 Enduro Package)
Tyres - Front130/90B16 67H90/90/21
Tyres - Rear150/80B16 77H150/70 - R17 (150/70 - R18 Enduro Package)
Wheels-Aluminium cross-spoke wheels
Wheels - FrontCast 8-spoke 16 in x 3.5 in-
Wheels - RearCast 5-spoke 16 in x 3.5 in-

Verdict

Winner on specs

2024 Indian Scout Bobber

The 2024 Indian Scout Bobber edges out the 2025 BMW R 12G/S thanks to its more peak power, lower seat height, liquid cooling and larger displacement. Specifications are one part of the picture - dealer support, parts availability, and intended use all matter too.

Key Differences

2024 Indian Scout Bobber - Advantages

  • More power: Produces 107 hp vs 81 kW - a meaningful performance advantage.
  • Lower seat height: 649 mm vs 860 mm - accessible to a wider range of rider heights.
  • Liquid cooling: Consistent engine temperature in stop-start traffic and hot climates.
  • Larger displacement: 1250 cc vs 1170 cc - more cubic capacity means broader torque delivery and greater low-end pull.

2025 BMW R 12G/S - Advantages

  • Standard ABS: A meaningful safety advantage in emergency braking on wet or loose surfaces.
  • Dual front discs: Greater stopping power and better heat management under hard braking.
  • More front wheel travel: 210 mm vs 119 mm - greater compliance over rough surfaces.

2024 Indian Scout Bobber vs 2025 BMW R 12G/S - FAQs

What are the engine differences between the 2024 Indian Scout Bobber and 2025 BMW R 12G/S?
The 2024 Indian Scout Bobber uses Four stroke, 60° V-Twin, DOHC, 4 valves per cylinder, while the 2025 BMW R 12G/S is powered by Four stroke, two cylinder horizontally opposed Boxer, with four camshaft-operated valves and two overhead camshafts per cylinder..
Which is lighter, the 2024 Indian Scout Bobber or the 2025 BMW R 12G/S?
The 2025 BMW R 12G/S is lighter at 229 kg compared to 237 kg for the 2024 Indian Scout Bobber - a difference of 8 kg. This is a small difference unlikely to be a deciding factor in everyday riding.
Which has more power, the 2024 Indian Scout Bobber or the 2025 BMW R 12G/S?
The 2024 Indian Scout Bobber produces more peak power at 107 hp, compared to 81 kW for the 2025 BMW R 12G/S.
Which bike is better for shorter riders, the 2024 Indian Scout Bobber or the 2025 BMW R 12G/S?
The 2024 Indian Scout Bobber has the lower seat at 649 mm, making it more accessible. The 2025 BMW R 12G/S sits higher at 860 mm. A seat height below 800 mm suits most riders; above 820 mm shorter riders may need to tiptoe.
Does the 2024 Indian Scout Bobber or 2025 BMW R 12G/S have ABS?
The 2025 BMW R 12G/S is listed with ABS as standard. The 2024 Indian Scout Bobber does not list ABS. ABS provides a meaningful safety benefit in emergency braking on wet or loose surfaces.
Which should I buy, the 2024 Indian Scout Bobber or the 2025 BMW R 12G/S?
Both are strong choices. The 2024 Indian Scout Bobber has the edge in more peak power and lower seat height, while the 2025 BMW R 12G/S stands out for standard ABS and dual front discs. Visit dealers, arrange test rides, and factor in local parts and service costs - these often matter as much as the spec sheet.